The sparks fly for Guy
It's the night of several firsts. It's the first time the forecourt of Bridgewater Hall, home to Britain's oldest
symphony orchestra, has been besieged in such a manner by ticket touts, and the first time in the
orchestra's illustrious 150-year history they have collaborated with a local guitar band. The second night
of the two will also be the first time a performance from the venue has been broadcast live to Castlefield
Arena, where thousands of ticketless fans have massed to watch a big-screen relay.
The collaboration has been several years in the making. The initial idea came from the Hallé, who
wanted to do something different around the time of their 150th anniversary. Elbow loved the idea, lead
singer Guy Garvey in particular, having been taken to the Hallé by his grandfather as a young Guy. The
Hallé are, after all, Garvey argues, "the original Manchester band". But it is Manchester International
Festival which has made tonight possible. This year's festival features an impressive international array of
talent, so there's a real sense of hometown pride that two local titans should be one of the highlights.
This is not the first time Elbow have embarked on such a collaboration. In January they performed their all
conquering The Seldom Seen Kid live with the BBC Concert Orchestra and Chantage, Radio 3's Choir of
the Year 2006, at Abbey Road Studios in London. But the Hallé collaboration was planned first and
Garvey has promised that "we saved the best stuff for the northern crew".
Elbow's oeuvre lends itself readily to such a collaboration. They have always specialised in cinematic,
complex, layered songs of multidimensional texture with a pace suited to orchestral backing, and much of
their songbook already has string backing, especially the last couple of albums. Garvey writes songs of
love and loss and the endurance of human emotions - love songs that run the full spectrum from the
desperate vacuum of unrequited love to the euphoric rush of the falling in love again for what feels like
the first time. At the festival launch, he revealed that his girlfriend had pointed out to him that he had
actually written more love songs about Manchester than about any girl. No songwriter since Morrissey
has found the city to be such an inspiring muse, all of which makes tonight even more fitting.
Tonight is also much more of a true collaboration than the Abbey Road performance. Salford-born
composer Joe Duddell, who has orchestrated and conducts the Hallé tonight, has written new
arrangements, expanding and reinterpreting songs from across their back catalogue. They open with
"Station Approach", Garvey's telling and affectionate ode to the sense of relief northerners get when
pulling into Piccadilly station - "I need to be in a town where they know what I'm like and don't mind". At its
close Garvey allows himself a moment to glance around the hall and savour the occasion. "This is a very,
very lovely thing" he smiles.
There's a new, slower, dreamy extended intro to "Mirrorball", Duddell's reimagining of the half light of
early morning depicted in its lyrics, before the signature piano motif drops in, fractured light bouncing
round the concert hall. Much of the first half is drawn from The Seldom Seen Kid, and if one song
illustrates the seismic change in Elbow's fortunes over the last few years it's "The Loneliness of a Tower
Crane Driver". The oldest track on the album, written at a time when their previous record deal was
coming to an end and they didn't have a new one, it's an epic song that aches with desperation,
frustration and longing whenever performed - during rehearsals for last year's Mercury Music Prize
ceremony their performance made old stage hands and hardened technicians cry - but given the added
scale and emphasis of a full orchestra, the effect is almost overwhelming.
On the more raucous "Grounds for Divorce", Garvey leads the audience to clap along and add backing
vocals. There follows a soaring and swooping version of "Some Riot", and the first half closes with a new
extended ending to "Weather to Fly" that prompts a standing ovation at the interval.
The second half draws from all four albums, old favourites such as "Scattered Black and Whites" and
"Powder Blue" from their 2001 debut Asleep in the Back only highlighting the strength of their back
catalogue. Duddell's new orchestrations simply add extra emphasis and scale at times, and at others take
the songs in a different direction or add totally new sections, at several points without the band
themselves. There's an ever-rising swell of goodwill and euphoria but thankfully it only threatens to boil
over during the inevitable closing "One Day Like This", the audience almost drowning out band and
orchestra, backed by the bells of Manchester town hall, which is projected on to the back of the stage.
It's a truly special night, but what is tantalising is you're left with a feeling that this is a band whose star is
still in the ascendant. As much as tonight was recognition of how far they have come and how much they
have achieved, there is the feeling that there is a lot more to expect from Elbow. This is a performance
that will be difficult to match, however. Garvey says it is an evening he will tell his grandchildren about.
One suspects he won't be the only guy to do so.
Luke Bainbridge, The Observer